Serve the shared Mempool explorer through the Angor indexer

2026-10-01 16:03:19 -04:00
parent 19c49c6605
commit 3acefecc24
9 changed files with 643 additions and 21 deletions
@@ -0,0 +1,112 @@
+# Angor client acceptance and remaining project recovery
+
+Status: **OPEN — live services and one complete project flow pass; full project recovery is incomplete.**
+
+The operator requires actual Angor-client verification and any necessary application
+fixes to reach the next OTA, app catalog and ISO. Main release owner acknowledged
+ownership of NPM/public management isolation; this investigation owns Angor evidence,
+app setup documentation and the scoped browser test. Do not treat this report as
+permission to waive the outstanding discovery/recovery requirements.
+
+## Verified live behavior
+
+- Trusted HTTPS indexer health, fees, address transactions and cursor pagination work.
+- Real browser requests from `https://angor.io` reach the selected custom indexer;
+  checked transaction IDs, confirmation data and output scripts match the reference.
+- The indexer serves all 35 funding transactions listed in the public reference
+  snapshot, confirmed, with matching original announcement commitments. This checks
+  that snapshot, not every possible Bitcoin address or the entire project universe.
+- Relay NIP-11 and encrypted WebSocket/Nostr read work. An invalid signature was
+  rejected before importing the valid original announcement; the original signed
+  announcement was accepted unchanged and read back exactly.
+- Imported ONLY the original public kind3030 event
+  `adbf94d6152097f3d503cd68cc00dee34c1e1007914c00cfc3d6698d1ee01834`, after checking its
+  Schnorr signature with nostr-tools and matching funding transaction
+  `72d14227b78a260c9410a65585cb49e81e35eaa95b1b23ec702eb0512ca016a7` on our indexer.
+  No fabricated, re-signed or modified announcement, wallet operation or payment.
+- Restarted only the managed Angor relay. Its original announcement persisted;
+  node-internal strfry container ID and start time remained unchanged.
+- Clean Chromium, configured with our indexer plus original relays and our relay,
+  now displays **Casa Bitcoin sv** in Explore and loads its full project page,
+  metadata, funding transaction and Project Statistics.
+- `tests/lifecycle/angor-public-browser.cjs` passes all three acceptance groups:
+  trusted public API/WSS and chain commitment; actual Explore discovery;
+  actual project details/statistics. It is opt-in and read-only, uses a disposable
+  profile and known immutable public fixture, and does not disable TLS checks.
+
+Live test command (run from repository root):
+
+```sh
+ANGOR_TEST_INDEXER=https://angor-indexer.tx1138.com/ \
+ANGOR_TEST_RELAY=wss://angor-relay.tx1138.com/ \
+ANGOR_TEST_RELAYS='["wss://relay.angor.io","wss://relay2.angor.io","wss://angor-relay.tx1138.com"]' \
+node tests/lifecycle/angor-public-browser.cjs
+```
+
+## Empty project list: reproduced upstream behavior
+
+The user retained the original relays. Our earlier suggestion that an empty new
+relay explained the entire failure was incorrect.
+
+Angor Hub v2.0.0 (`main-575CWKJX.js`) was tested in separate clean Chromium profiles
+using our indexer and `https://indexer.angor.io/`. Both received candidate Nostr
+announcements, but the current batch failed validation: `event-mismatch` for
+updated announcements of one funded project, and `not-found-in-mempool` for another
+address that both indexers correctly return empty. Both displayed zero projects.
+The default primary `fulcrum.angor.online` separately failed browser CORS in a
+fresh default-config test. These upstream failures must not be attributed to
+missing data in our indexer without evidence.
+
+Current `block-core/angor-hub` `src/app/services/indexer.service.ts` discovers
+kind3030 events, filters by network, and calls `validateAndAddProjects` in the
+background. When a batch has candidates but none validate, it does not continue
+discovery to older valid original announcements. The Load More UI is unavailable
+when the project list is empty. An empty relay can coexist with this bug but is
+not its sole cause. After the authentic announcement was copied to our relay,
+one original passed the unchanged validation and appeared. This is a bounded
+history-availability recovery, NOT an upstream UI fix or global relay sync.
+
+The current browser uses ordinary `/api/v1/address/.../txs`, not the deprecated
+`/api/v1/query/Angor/projects` listing. Our adapter's 404 for the latter is NOT the
+observed browser failure. Do not add an opaque upstream proxy to hide that 404.
+
+## Other projects remain unresolved
+
+The public reference query returned 35 project records (limit50). All35 on-chain
+funding commitments were verified through our indexer. Exact original-event-ID
+queries were sent to the configured relays `relay.angor.io`, `relay2.angor.io`,
+`nos.lol`, `relay.primal.net`, and `relay.damus.io` (Damus had an initial connection
+failure, then answered EOSE on retry). Only one original announcement was found.
+Additional queries to `relay.snort.social`, `nostr.mom`, and `no.str.cr` returned
+no matches; `relay.nostr.band` and `relay.f7z.io` were unavailable. This does not
+prove the other34 events are globally lost or that all storage sources were checked.
+
+Exact project IDs, transaction IDs, event IDs and confirmed commitment results:
+[recovery inventory](angor-project-recovery-20261001.json). Recover originals from
+founders/known archives or authoritative relay backups and retain their signatures.
+On-chain commitments cannot reconstruct missing off-chain project content.
+Do not fabricate replacements or accept mismatched events to make cards appear.
+
+## Release handoff and open gates
+
+- [x] Release owner acknowledges these final findings and the 34-project gap.
+      Confirmed 2026-10-01 18:46:50 UTC in `/tmp/angor-final-handoff-ack.txt`: full
+      recovery remains open; publication held for required gates; preserve relay
+      data and rerun browser acceptance after bridge migration and OTA.
+- [ ] Resolve or explicitly carry the upstream discovery bug with accurate user
+      guidance; do not claim full recovery because the fixture passes.
+- [ ] Locate and verify remaining original project metadata/history, or obtain an
+      explicit operator scope decision; one project is not complete acceptance.
+- [ ] Preserve the verified public relay event/data through the candidate upgrade.
+- [ ] Repeat scoped browser acceptance after NPM bridge migration and OTA install.
+- [ ] Verify fresh ISO setup, NPM host propagation, public IP/default-host isolation,
+      certificate issuance/renewal and relay WebSocket routing; see NPM handoff.
+- [ ] Include updated app setup documentation and the read-only acceptance test.
+      No Angor image/config change was justified by the verified transaction data;
+      no image or catalog version should be bumped solely to disguise upstream failure.
+- [ ] Existing signed transaction-broadcast integration tests remain required;
+      this live investigation did not send real Bitcoin or test a funded investment.
+
+Raw local diagnostic logs are in `/tmp/angor-*-browser*.log` and
+`/tmp/angor-public-browser-acceptance.log`. The durable facts and recovery inventory
+above must remain available after temporary logs expire.
@@ -0,0 +1,286 @@
+{
+  "status": "INCOMPLETE: 34 original announcements not recovered from queried relays",
+  "source_inventory": "https://indexer.angor.io/api/v1/query/Angor/projects?limit=50",
+  "projects": [
+    {
+      "project": "angor1qryhse38vcyqnp0j6976q9f00a9jpj2ary03nlc",
+      "txid": "72d14227b78a260c9410a65585cb49e81e35eaa95b1b23ec702eb0512ca016a7",
+      "event_id": "adbf94d6152097f3d503cd68cc00dee34c1e1007914c00cfc3d6698d1ee01834",
+      "confirmed": true,
+      "commitment_matches": true,
+      "original_announcement_recovered": true
+    },
+    {
+      "project": "angor1q3eh4xg7t2hge7ctqk4yhmj7q23t6mdqa0ahg28",
+      "txid": "f5ff2e1a6b7340ddb9944c2ae6477c6b0b12993c9919f6e9b7b9e7a5e9a68f6d",
+      "event_id": "f4417e39c9b47afafd84cdda2017207e0929df2852badbf8d909bf6f647f4f2d",
+      "confirmed": true,
+      "commitment_matches": true,
+      "original_announcement_recovered": false
+    },
+    {
+      "project": "angor1qde7y830vtajref5vwag5x459m9w5y75gd49v4t",
+      "txid": "205ce39688572ef0168c1c1231c25ec632abb2c2b64c52fccb4f53eb0a49e300",
+      "event_id": "ca76084c2bc3301f8fe00dd8a93c6d6c0ad015e50676cdd3e44c8bd765f157d5",
+      "confirmed": true,
+      "commitment_matches": true,
+      "original_announcement_recovered": false
+    },
+    {
+      "project": "angor1q9k9976ytwkkmswlq24e89l2fxuxl57gfp8yxgr",
+      "txid": "00a0120818698ef3d72d360e29e9e4e7d0a35c180967186d1e715aef797c26a8",
+      "event_id": "a04d1eed8c1261cb5fca6a6faf16a5f87a9672cf40d1117b25f2da60e6e8f84c",
+      "confirmed": true,
+      "commitment_matches": true,
+      "original_announcement_recovered": false
+    },
+    {
+      "project": "angor1q67h8cktwy8yv32t0uk0c8zrtpmtwgtd56sylzx",
+      "txid": "1bfa726353a40d5fce1a76ad86dc7915bee214573d30d5751cd6312c94519089",
+      "event_id": "b3189f84b490da422e17b6b857d393b13781bb82e1c8813328769e3d2840098a",
+      "confirmed": true,
+      "commitment_matches": true,
+      "original_announcement_recovered": false
+    },
+    {
+      "project": "angor1qm999ekmrdjl4sq3qywl889w74qetxe3ghdxthl",
+      "txid": "ae9d471dd6e58b318120fbdf72929c621cf23d9c6f047df3c57923a8a915d01c",
+      "event_id": "89ae5e612e857f89dbbdc662198b894f1f7b70564769bedf08ec37f5e7b5efe0",
+      "confirmed": true,
+      "commitment_matches": true,
+      "original_announcement_recovered": false
+    },
+    {
+      "project": "angor1qtunna00uqyx52rr0nvqa059z2gknhrmn7urd6z",
+      "txid": "c2cb77ebf6b9ded802b677c600c3869b81fc76f31a3e4742b6a9cb16e0ac3dee",
+      "event_id": "f5e66707f8fa0fc601bef403020e64d9a164d6cf201599ec0c3ddb0acf58491e",
+      "confirmed": true,
+      "commitment_matches": true,
+      "original_announcement_recovered": false
+    },
+    {
+      "project": "angor1qu8h0ezv596z35uggg0r0ppkma93tnreyjg5du7",
+      "txid": "fb6bc0b721810957ae8910d5dd6e7ebc45d804a3e1f636d153df50f036e90645",
+      "event_id": "ce61a11b79aa258238db63f67472341169944bce02600045bf7278992aeb796c",
+      "confirmed": true,
+      "commitment_matches": true,
+      "original_announcement_recovered": false
+    },
+    {
+      "project": "angor1q8u9c2h2l0eqjn3qeyvdps89dkkvwteg5q3m708",
+      "txid": "04ed05297e146206c104c7b5d8a51fc3453f1829950675b4694f91a7ea609be1",
+      "event_id": "f31c6ef3a66e74ebfc26f5b2905e6d4641f73bdb407aa92022a2202b9be54716",
+      "confirmed": true,
+      "commitment_matches": true,
+      "original_announcement_recovered": false
+    },
+    {
+      "project": "angor1qqnxefpr4f59r5f4u34c7crzst2ya83wavh8407",
+      "txid": "bae879110e78ad44624980ea4a47de21b03d3994139714bb09e910187027583d",
+      "event_id": "cbd23077098059c5092bb7ea8df14dd73f21d47d1b690ff1e6fa789ad118864b",
+      "confirmed": true,
+      "commitment_matches": true,
+      "original_announcement_recovered": false
+    },
+    {
+      "project": "angor1qfydf802v2efvxufevrfg0mvtlrxln63rkzmdxw",
+      "txid": "4bbb04fed973c968e76faaca880197092be288d9897072ab5e6dfb719c19eb69",
+      "event_id": "e9761e1303de7eca0ade33936489d2b4b7d51f4b52e8ecbc1acfc394df48b95d",
+      "confirmed": true,
+      "commitment_matches": true,
+      "original_announcement_recovered": false
+    },
+    {
+      "project": "angor1qpt96uj5jg77q5566pmcdggyuztt26xn3xymwhn",
+      "txid": "bc46fea91acf4714f5b7949e9bb937f39e425468242c2459b581a14914e641b4",
+      "event_id": "f683c12dbc3d574797bd2251d7e9d96e1d33d6263f75a1538d2ce5fd0c86e064",
+      "confirmed": true,
+      "commitment_matches": true,
+      "original_announcement_recovered": false
+    },
+    {
+      "project": "angor1q3nleprspa3h6thy9c25wzu4q7ywajhcdg3j9au",
+      "txid": "7b76a8297f16ad5ff3d69fc85e37405ad4f77a71dfc8f70206a5a9c1827698ba",
+      "event_id": "893e5b7f09a12368f208120deb9c02b3692aee15240a914fb428e7e4f86b1123",
+      "confirmed": true,
+      "commitment_matches": true,
+      "original_announcement_recovered": false
+    },
+    {
+      "project": "angor1qc8jlugwgp90vzkhf336d8exldhwd8z5u4ssaen",
+      "txid": "5e06eb3684bf0d3402d20d643d6fe1b5a295680a29db440e070a89f80e52a241",
+      "event_id": "375eafd0e03c50d683de4f465501e919a8816ae618ca2b5c14e8d3f56daa90c0",
+      "confirmed": true,
+      "commitment_matches": true,
+      "original_announcement_recovered": false
+    },
+    {
+      "project": "angor1qdhwn7s0p8wcr9kw2932m448y6hd8ywl005fdwu",
+      "txid": "7cc5bff45f0b5e9ae81cadaf787dd4d4680387ab9fddedf8438eae8f87ef34ec",
+      "event_id": "6c7767eaf6ee0ae4ffe4b23c8477f2293216279e5908dd979abd4abdf1557578",
+      "confirmed": true,
+      "commitment_matches": true,
+      "original_announcement_recovered": false
+    },
+    {
+      "project": "angor1q8qzylut0gv7urycxukdfumzw6znghrk4g928k2",
+      "txid": "2c7eed8d9b8eef530a4a8f39339f7dfaa82d5ec09261305203d1a367a624be1b",
+      "event_id": "24323aae4bca910ddb48544b788860119c3cc13ac19b24694221f1ba2521cd6b",
+      "confirmed": true,
+      "commitment_matches": true,
+      "original_announcement_recovered": false
+    },
+    {
+      "project": "angor1qzwrm6hf5l0tgen99anr9hj7ylk38v6zhmnq7w0",
+      "txid": "934c45244c283ff24834bab7d01a0964192433cd2bc11143fc5e590b2b954deb",
+      "event_id": "6cfae243c276a602ce2da33842ad930019d75e80ffe81b4cd84b1b187830bba7",
+      "confirmed": true,
+      "commitment_matches": true,
+      "original_announcement_recovered": false
+    },
+    {
+      "project": "angor1qpdp5d2ahknhtr7kawsl62m7y4hktsfn4uwg6r3",
+      "txid": "dc85d36b324ff829a4d49a606573e136fbc29498bc707d95f5bd0d9ef49956d0",
+      "event_id": "c6d22deef6d1babc99716746f50509e5413b97445d991a0869f0567b7301fc97",
+      "confirmed": true,
+      "commitment_matches": true,
+      "original_announcement_recovered": false
+    },
+    {
+      "project": "angor1q9v88fe2q2efr4z57wed4gklmkh7trmx6usac0d",
+      "txid": "b98b23e49630f92ac0dedb7e0a8ac5ad2c51f813039f2d9dd708c9a0861b2ca2",
+      "event_id": "e8f518eaed658e9331b3a3feba49f36eda5eb7fe68c81c7b3f71057844729bcb",
+      "confirmed": true,
+      "commitment_matches": true,
+      "original_announcement_recovered": false
+    },
+    {
+      "project": "angor1q0gtztyk24ea2028ewfn026838k3ll322qrvrhu",
+      "txid": "31b38cf48cf18936b7c370ee72e8bda6e9ee40f24ec676a85b9b8b1abefebdd4",
+      "event_id": "fe34db328e51cc10f9c4d035b0f0aab7f9137a4cdee3a2afc4c6610404e79fe4",
+      "confirmed": true,
+      "commitment_matches": true,
+      "original_announcement_recovered": false
+    },
+    {
+      "project": "angor1q65fuwpyvek3fxk5p757zyknjd9k9sava3fd98j",
+      "txid": "0b7bf7b9119157edc778bcdc7088b70a439fa5dc8c46e839b95fd2f0a8fbf046",
+      "event_id": "991d0f7d1c261e4d79507238e3d5e4b3d3adce267cf40107ee2ade32485f5cf6",
+      "confirmed": true,
+      "commitment_matches": true,
+      "original_announcement_recovered": false
+    },
+    {
+      "project": "angor1qjqfp23ac4s4llgcgs3qnenjhpasgrmvt373usp",
+      "txid": "8b4887aba04b12729e609658b0fdbb1e6f1b172ba10360c7a5261c3e9bd590f9",
+      "event_id": "254910567be531d7862afcbcc80b490ee92a5f9ed801424f3d56108d9a114b80",
+      "confirmed": true,
+      "commitment_matches": true,
+      "original_announcement_recovered": false
+    },
+    {
+      "project": "angor1qfyzk83tqznc3aqg5ly0cewn7ytsrwl474v4dyn",
+      "txid": "3e2ea870b17eab2023a04dca267c45d2c53a41abb3f20b206e095fcbba6c5f02",
+      "event_id": "1e27aa63f276048ba78ef73f69dc5045441feafaa090aff9b995341883f22fb4",
+      "confirmed": true,
+      "commitment_matches": true,
+      "original_announcement_recovered": false
+    },
+    {
+      "project": "angor1qw7m67a5r6vpmtw2jqpsp4xtxvtu6mmnkgj6gxw",
+      "txid": "f3d3549b2a30c78e7c3b51bc9122e0ae8a7ecb378f9b3564ebf931769637df49",
+      "event_id": "fc4289a4888bfe157588e507204d93723a8c07074cde37bb98cf866793f81c98",
+      "confirmed": true,
+      "commitment_matches": true,
+      "original_announcement_recovered": false
+    },
+    {
+      "project": "angor1qgdc07hkk0l4kntg2k5fczk7tcx0qeqqx2saru0",
+      "txid": "c1332c51da2c5706f6fc74e3275856438304a7761ced4dcd2e738a7e3c62bd2f",
+      "event_id": "ae1d1f7f883907dea36902fc2dc78c8ad81d22bd59bd7293ba1725c6cc959846",
+      "confirmed": true,
+      "commitment_matches": true,
+      "original_announcement_recovered": false
+    },
+    {
+      "project": "angor1qhklyl9mw5zwzwynxv6ekaz5f9h5zv3wnd8dn2c",
+      "txid": "be637cd8a23c80f49195345eca5d4c29bf4a9fa0600e0625af702444e300d218",
+      "event_id": "78a1443b14cb252b2510925263889e8c8f40b12fd911d137d63b1dbc2b841a3a",
+      "confirmed": true,
+      "commitment_matches": true,
+      "original_announcement_recovered": false
+    },
+    {
+      "project": "angor1q4heck5tf6svq7x8jp5twak329xtv9805xppvq5",
+      "txid": "509db524eba0b90e8607396e9eb42ed379a270f3aa602a0bc16eec050c959823",
+      "event_id": "dec392d7d962e7dfd2c9eaa2b05dfc03c909d87982c4d73b9f321dc13487622f",
+      "confirmed": true,
+      "commitment_matches": true,
+      "original_announcement_recovered": false
+    },
+    {
+      "project": "angor1qc6gykcw82hu3pa4pn94gfxwgpp8dewlsh45rwc",
+      "txid": "087390128a78270cd1465656e3ab63b9b47982dca1a910b7a5664f67f8ab9970",
+      "event_id": "cf634987daa4ee17bb2d160ddb04ce56a0d73e664b9822e5e9a8edf870630a9c",
+      "confirmed": true,
+      "commitment_matches": true,
+      "original_announcement_recovered": false
+    },
+    {
+      "project": "angor1qfzxd8n94r592gt3mrmgwe7knk6dhajmutpuhkx",
+      "txid": "29cb361fe78b6f199f169b7b4a7d9663b7e7f46607f382ddcf8cb2224a6023f1",
+      "event_id": "ca7a6e0bb27beb46fb8e709378908feb5357e7edd43a9262318cadf72da5f141",
+      "confirmed": true,
+      "commitment_matches": true,
+      "original_announcement_recovered": false
+    },
+    {
+      "project": "angor1q0whhl3qgq28g443h9mj6dl8n2ssshm6hkd3xse",
+      "txid": "4d70fba03ec51d87df7df16498a95a907b9cff00035455e3ab8242935f260030",
+      "event_id": "3a19b34d76ec7b99eb98ed299737c06cd3710268febf7d2acf6ce1fece9ba459",
+      "confirmed": true,
+      "commitment_matches": true,
+      "original_announcement_recovered": false
+    },
+    {
+      "project": "angor1q2a5m2zcwpmkh49z05pg6gd9cxm4dhx3ywfclem",
+      "txid": "5da06a119db273bbb7c64e2cc103a8edb48a9934ab9b5b972ae55f697023ce07",
+      "event_id": "8c3a8dcaf9c55e7797cf4ff9a25b0e7cd7dcbe78c8ed248d53a49c70f9ea4a6b",
+      "confirmed": true,
+      "commitment_matches": true,
+      "original_announcement_recovered": false
+    },
+    {
+      "project": "angor1qq9ngpm2w8xss5sf0amt63z076y2x885wh0jfv7",
+      "txid": "7f42da75e4b3dd92f9870aefa177c2fb3783f189996abf193b3b353ee21e805e",
+      "event_id": "2f0c6e3b29a74be45033062742b3fbac4a4c7b7be4eeecc7021df4a8b1b195cf",
+      "confirmed": true,
+      "commitment_matches": true,
+      "original_announcement_recovered": false
+    },
+    {
+      "project": "angor1qwdgxjuzhjykgpn5q8p3l2q9vyrgqdlrkfp5sjr",
+      "txid": "c15d07fd14d58e7204889ba24fe47a9b86aa7bea9992d30f4be36864e7634725",
+      "event_id": "733b28b35f771839bc719125af94916a5400675185d4a75edb09645c8eb4cc24",
+      "confirmed": true,
+      "commitment_matches": true,
+      "original_announcement_recovered": false
+    },
+    {
+      "project": "angor1qyuj8z532tnhy7srutwecu3j789z22peu2t8c7v",
+      "txid": "821193743f7ca7b0b178a78379d79f5783d874a182a8bf36b70a0a2a6cb12d24",
+      "event_id": "56fce837c628728953138ca57895c7ef9533640a989934c432d1040808781b9f",
+      "confirmed": true,
+      "commitment_matches": true,
+      "original_announcement_recovered": false
+    },
+    {
+      "project": "angor1qznva9wmw3anr7qdhhs4v0xptd0pz07gdr2fuwz",
+      "txid": "187e39a0ba9714ae3543bbe775dd9fff9c7a4ac946ce0a850480c3871de287fe",
+      "event_id": "baff907b6f1fb97893e63e1bef6919f819c1b6e37560ed2d4255b77cc26d08cd",
+      "confirmed": true,
+      "commitment_matches": true,
+      "original_announcement_recovered": false
+    }
+  ]
+}